When it comes to chasing waves across the globe, two destinations stand out for their untamed beauty and world-class surf — the Mentawai Islands and New Zealand. One is a tropical surfing paradise off the coast of Indonesia, while the other delivers cool, rugged coastlines with a rich surf culture. But which one should you choose for your next surf travel adventure? Let’s dive in and find out.
Surf Culture: Island Rhythm vs. Kiwi Soul
Mentawai Islands
The Mentawai Islands surf scene is steeped in purity — pure waves, pure lifestyle, pure escape. These Indonesian islands are remote and raw, built for surfers who want to disconnect from the digital world and reconnect with the rhythm of the ocean. Villages are small, the vibe is slow, and the entire experience is about hunting the perfect wave. Local surf guides are often surfers themselves, adding to the grassroots charm that makes Mentawai feel like home for those in search of something deeper.
New Zealand
New Zealand’s surf culture runs deep in its rugged coastlines and beach towns. With a laid-back, welcoming spirit, the Kiwi surf scene thrives on exploration and community. From the North Island’s long beach breaks to the South Island’s wild points and reefs, surfing here is a way of life. While Mentawai offers a more secluded experience, New Zealand brings a mix of surf with road-trip freedom, perfect for adventure-loving travelers who want surf with variety.
Wave Quality: Tropical Perfection vs. Southern Power
Mentawai Islands
Consistency is the name of the game in the Mentawais. From April to October, this archipelago lights up with Indian Ocean swells, delivering everything from playful peaks to hollow freight trains. Breaks like Kandui, HT’s, and Rifles are legendary. Whether you’re learning to read reef setups or chasing deep barrels, these Mentawai waves offer something for every skill level. With boat trips and surf camps offering access to dozens of breaks, this is a surfer’s dream with uncrowded lineups and endless swell.
New Zealand
New Zealand’s coastline — especially on the west — is pounded by Southern Ocean energy, offering great waves for much of the year. Spots like Raglan serve up long, dreamy lefts, while beaches like Piha and Muriwai pack punch. But conditions change fast — wind, tides, and swell direction can make sessions a hit or miss. It’s more for surfers who enjoy the thrill of the chase. If you score, it’s magic. If not, the journey’s still worth it. You’ll find big wave surfing potential at places like Shipwreck Bay or Papatowai — if you’re bold enough.
Accommodation: Remote Retreat vs. Road Trip Ready
Mentawai Islands
In the Mentawais, your front door often opens straight onto the beach. Whether you choose a rustic surf camp or a boutique stay like Bela Sulu Villas, you’ll be immersed in nature. These oceanfront villa rental accommodations are designed for surfers: paddle out at sunrise, rinse off under a palm tree, and refuel with fresh local meals. It’s all about staying close to the surf without sacrificing comfort. Ideal for surfers who value peace, quiet, and proximity to world-class breaks.
New Zealand
New Zealand’s surf accommodations are as diverse as its coastlines. You’ll find camper vans, cozy lodges, and beachside motels. The country is built for road trips, so most surfers explore from coast to coast — sleeping in vans, pitching tents, or booking Airbnbs as they go. It’s flexible, affordable, and adventure-driven, though not always next to the surf. For comfort, you’ll trade proximity. But for road trip romance? Few places beat New Zealand.
Natural Beauty: Jungle Serenity vs. Untamed Wild
Mentawai Islands
Imagine a place where turquoise water meets white sand, backed by dense jungle and ancient trees. The Mentawai Islands offer a rare and untouched natural setting. Wildlife is abundant — from monkeys and birds to vibrant marine life. The islands are remote, serene, and deeply spiritual. It’s a nature-lover’s paradise, and one that supports a soul-stirring surf travel experience. When you’re not surfing, you’re swimming in lagoons, hiking waterfalls, or relaxing in hammocks under the sun. Planning a surf trip? Make sure you’re fully prepared with the ultimate surf trip packing essentials to gear up for your tropical adventure.
New Zealand
New Zealand stuns with dramatic coastlines, snow-capped peaks, rolling green hills, and geothermal wonders. It’s one of the most visually striking countries on Earth. While the waves are great, the scenery often steals the show. Between sessions, you can hike volcanoes, soak in hot springs, explore glowworm caves, or cruise fjords. Surfing here is part of a broader adventure. If you love a variety of landscapes and action-packed days, this country delivers on all fronts.
Which Destination is Right for You?
Choosing between the Mentawai Islands and New Zealand comes down to what kind of surf trip you crave. If you want consistent surf, warm water, and the rhythm of island life, the Mentawai Islands surf delivers with unmatched power and tranquility. For those drawn to road trips, cooler climates, and rugged adventure, New Zealand offers a raw and rewarding surf experience. But if your goal is to find the perfect wave, surf multiple world-class breaks in a single trip, and experience remote paradise, then Mentawai is the destination calling your name.
Stay at Bela Sulu Villas for the Ultimate Island Escape
Ready to experience the best of the Mentawai waves with a touch of luxury? Bela Sulu Villas offers oceanfront villa rental accommodations on the remote island of Siberut, surrounded by pristine surf breaks.
Whether you’re chasing barrels or soaking in tropical beauty, our villas provide the ideal blend of comfort, privacy, and surf access. Enjoy gourmet meals, lush gardens, and the soundtrack of the ocean just steps away. Book your surf trip today and discover why the Mentawai Islands are the crown jewel of surfing islands.
